Warehouse Robotics: The Potential of Physical Integration

Robotics & Warehouse Automation

September 2024

Rueben Scriven

Senior Research Manager

Rueben is one of the world’s leading warehouse automation industry analysts. He’s spoken at all the leading industry events, and featured in the Financial Times, the WSJ, The Economist, Reuters, and CNBC, along with countless trade publications. He leads the Warehouse Automation research practice at Interact Analysis, a market intelligence firm focused on supply chain automation technologies. In recent years, his group’s research and analysis has expanded into warehouse software covering the whole tech-stack from sub-system control software, to execution and management software.

Warehouses are intricate environments, bustling with various moving parts. In many respects, they function like living organisms, constantly adapting and responding to external stimuli. For instance, if demand for a specific product surges or declines, warehouse processes must adjust accordingly. This adaptability is especially crucial in sectors like e-commerce, where the end market is highly dynamic, requiring frequent modifications to workflows as consumer preferences evolve.

While fixed warehouse automation solutions have significantly improved throughput, they often lack flexibility and are challenging to adjust or modify once installed. Robotic solutions offer greater adaptability, enabling warehouse operators to modify workflows more easily. However, altering robotic workflows can still take days or even months due to the extensive software integration required. For example, integrating a robotic picking system into a workflow that utilizes a material transport autonomous mobile robot (AMR) necessitates an API connection between the two systems, both of which must also be integrated with the host system, such as the WMS.

This contrasts sharply with human labor. In a manual warehouse, adjusting a workflow only requires updating the workflow in the WMS and training the human operator on the changes. There is no need to “integrate” the human with a new storage system or material transport AMR. Instead, operators only need instructions, relying on their physical senses – such as vision, touch, and kinaesthetic awareness (the ability to sense movement) – to adapt to the new workflow.

The Promise of Physical Integration

Physical integration represents the next frontier in warehouse robotics. Consider a recent GXO project involving an Ocado material transport AMR (formally 6RS) and an Agility humanoid robot named Digit. In this scenario, the 6RS AMR delivers a tote to the humanoid robot, which then transfers the tote from the AMR to a nearby conveyor system.

Although the video doesn’t clarify whether there is software integration between the humanoid robot and the AMR, the future of robotics may not require such integration. Instead, humanoid robots could rely solely on physical integration; using vision, kinaesthetic awareness, and touch to connect with upstream automation systems.

While this might seem like a small shift, the implications are profound. Imagine an automation solution that can be reconfigured using a drag-and-drop interface. Multiple automation systems could work together seamlessly without software-level integration, requiring only physical senses to integrate with adjacent workflows. This approach could redefine what it means to have a flexible warehouse automation system.

Challenges of Physical Integration

Although physical integration is the future direction for warehouse robotics, several obstacles must be overcome. First, physical integration still requires communication with the host system. When one workflow ends and another begins, the host system needs to be informed. Standardizing this information transfer remains a challenge, as different systems communicate with the host in various ways. Automated data capture systems, such as QR codes, will become increasingly vital. For example, when a humanoid robot picks up a tote from a material transport AMR, it is likely to have to inform the host system via QR code capture.

Secondly, robots must be “taught” to physically sense different upstream automation systems. If, for example, you replace an Ocado material transport AMR with a Locus Robotics AMR, the downstream picking robot (such as a humanoid robot) must perform the same workflow despite the different physical delivery system.

This task is relatively easy with software integration. However, relying solely on physical integration demands that the downstream robot intuitively understands how to pick the tote from the new AMR platform. Both Ocado (formally 6RS) and Locus Robotics AMRs provide physical cues for human pickers, such as lights highlighting which tote to pick or screens displaying instructions. Robots designed for physical integration will need to use similar cues to perform tasks correctly.

The Role of “Light” Software Integration

Throughout this discussion, we’ve emphasized how robots might physically integrate with upstream and downstream workflows, interacting with adjacent automation systems using physical senses instead of relying on deep software integration. This approach allows robots to adapt to new workflows more easily, much like the ways in which humans use physical cues like vision and touch.

However, if we assume deep software integration will eventually become obsolete, we can reimagine how robots might communicate with one another. In addition to physical integration, robots could use Bluetooth or other short-range communication protocols to supplement existing physical cues, such as pick-to-light systems and monitors displaying written instructions. In the GXO example, the Ocado robot might transmit instructions to the humanoid robot via Bluetooth, directing it towards the tote to pick.

At this point, it may seem like we’ve come full circle, discussing software integration once again. However, the key difference is that using short-range communication protocols like Bluetooth does not require upfront software integration if the communication protocols are standardized. Moreover, these protocols would augment, rather than replace, the physical integration, which should theoretically be enough on its own.

Final Thoughts

Physical integration is poised to be a transformative technology for future warehouses, where robots and humans work seamlessly together. Each agent, whether human or robot, performs its own workflow in isolation, with physical integrations linking the workflows together. When viewed in isolation, each operation might seem simple and unremarkable. However, when considered as part of a broader system, these physical integrations create a complex, intelligent network that functions much like a living organism.

LATEST ROBOTICS & WAREHOUSE AUTOMATION INSIGHTS

Loading...